Sonic justice: 10 songs about the law

Simon Edward • Oct 13, 2023

Many songwriters and musicians have been inspired by the law – from run-ins with the police to full-blown court cases. Discover ten of the best in our blog.


Many songwriters and musicians have been inspired by the law – from run-ins with the police to full-blown court cases. Discover ten of the best in our blog.

The legal world touches on a huge amount of human drama and intrigue. It's a lawyer's job to stay impartial in the heat of a legal wrangle – but artists and musicians can tap into those emotions with exciting (and catchy) results.


In this blog post, we run through ten songs about the law – from radio staples to lesser-known gems. 


First up: a punk-rock classic.


1. The Clash: "I Fought the Law"


Although written in 1958 and first recorded by the Bobby Fuller Four, "I Fought the Law" is a song that most people associate with British punks The Clash.


The song is written from the perspective of a man sentenced to work on a chain gang because of his gun-toting ways. Worst of all, he lost his baby somewhere along the way.


Fun fact: the clanging noises at the end were created by hitting the pipes in the studio toilet with hammers.


2. Bob Marley and the Wailers: "I Shot the Sheriff"


A staple at summer barbecues everywhere, Bob Marley's "I Shot the Sheriff" was in fact inspired by police brutality.


Marley explained: "I want to say 'I shot the police' but the government would have made a fuss so I said 'I shot the sheriff' instead… but it's the same idea: justice."


In the song, the narrator shoots Sheriff John Brown "in self-defence" because he was "aiming to shoot me down" – and, it's implied, not for the first time.


3. Simon and Garfunkel: "Wednesday Morning, 3AM"


This 1963 song by Simon and Garfunkel starts in the thick of things: the aftermath of a stick-up at a liquor store. But we find our hero (or antihero) not in the jailhouse but lying next to "the girl that I love". He sings softly, painfully aware that he will soon have to leave her and face justice.


Part of the tragedy is that the narrator didn't even gain much from the crime: just "twenty-five dollars and pieces of silver". And those "pieces of silver", with their allusion to Judas's betrayal of Jesus, suggest that perhaps he betrayed a friend or partner, too.


4. Bob Dylan: "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll"


In the early 1960s, Bob Dylan wrote several songs about the mistreatment of African-Americans. Many of these were torn from the headlines of the day.


"The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll" is a factual retelling of the murder of a 51-year-old African-American barmaid named Hattie Carroll by a young white tobacco heir named William Zantzinger.


The last verse of the song takes us to the courtroom, where the judge "spoke through his cloak, most deep and distinguished" and hands out a mere six-month sentence to Zantzinger.


5. The Merseybeats: "I Stand Accused"


This slice of early 60s pop compares the narrator's love for a taken woman to a "big crime". He imagines being taken to the "witness stand" and having to testify to his love. Worst of all, he's "unable to lie" and "got a love that won't die".


This song is a time capsule, showing the influence of American rock 'n' roll on British acts. It's no coincidence that they use the American English phrase "witness stand" rather than referring to a homegrown "witness box".


6. Leonard Cohen: "A Singer Must Die"


This song from 1974 imagines a courtroom where the artist is interrogated by the "keepers of truth" and "guardians of beauty".


These guardians seem to represent the state. This was a time, after all, when artists were more vulnerable to state censorship than today.


The singer has to pretend to respect the state ("Yes, and long live the state by whoever it's made") and even come up with an alibi ("Sir, I didn't see nothing, I was just getting home late").


7. Randy Newman: "Jolly Coppers on Parade"


This 1978 track by Randy Newman seems to be sung from the perspective of a child watching the police parade through town. The child admires how "they look so nice… like angels have come down from paradise". One day, the child reflects, they'll be a policeman too.


Randy Newman is an artist who likes to tip a wink to the audience – so we probably shouldn't take this at face value. We're probably being asked to reflect on the distance between what the child sees and the realities of modern policing.


8. Morrissey: "The More You Ignore Me, The Closer I Get"


Morrissey is someone who's had his own scrapes with the law – most notably the High Court case brought against him by his ex-bandmate, who wanted fairer royalties from the music they made together.


The judge – the marvellously named Judge Justice Weeks – famously ruled that Morrissey was "devious, truculent and unreliable when his own interests were at stake".


So it's perhaps no surprise that his song "The More You Ignore Me, The Closer I Get" contains the threatening lines: "Beware, I bear more grudges / Than lonely High Court judges".


9. Common: Testify


American rapper Common's "Testify" is a song with a twist. It describes a familiar scene – a man on trial for "murder and gun possession". His wife, in tears, sings the song's hook: "Before you lock my love away / Please let me testify".


However (spoiler alert) it turns out that the woman herself did the crime – and her tears are a cover as this mendacious "queenpin" lets her husband go down.


10. Taylor Swift: "Anti-Hero"


Taylor Swift's witty "Anti-Hero" is most famous for its line "It's me! Hi! I'm the problem, it's me". But it's also a song that features a fantasy about probate.


Taylor has a recurring dream that her "daughter-in-law kills me for the money", only to discover that she wasn't in the will. When this is discovered, another family member "screams out / 'She's laughing up at us from hell'".


The daughter-in-law may have a case against Taylor – but the act of murder could complicate things.


Milners is a trusted team of solicitors in Yorkshire. We pride ourselves on providing no-nonsense, jargon-free advice, backed up by years of legal expertise. For a free initial consultation, don't hesitate to get in touch.

What happens to our online presence when we pass away? Learn how to navigate this
by Simon Edward 25 Mar, 2024
What happens to our online presence when we pass away? Learn how to navigate this "virtual estate".
It's been called the biggest miscarriage of justice in UK history. Learn about the Post Office
by Simon Edward 22 Mar, 2024
It's been called the biggest miscarriage of justice in UK history. Learn about the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry.
Are you looking to buy a house without a mortgage? You've got options. Find out more
by Simon Edward 18 Mar, 2024
Are you looking to buy a house without a mortgage? You've got options. Find out more in our explainer article.
Does inheritance tax apply to you? Find out in our handy guide to this commonly misunderstood issue.
by Simon Edward 15 Mar, 2024
Does inheritance tax apply to you? Find out in our handy guide to this commonly misunderstood issue.
Employment law distinguishes between workers and employees. Learn the difference
by Simon Edward 11 Mar, 2024
Employment law distinguishes between workers and employees. Learn the difference in our handy article.
What is criminal damage in British law? Join us as we explore the topic
by Simon Edward 08 Mar, 2024
What is criminal damage in British law? Join us as we explore the topic in our accessible 5-minute guide.
When you get a divorce, the financial settlement will include any business assets. Find out more
by Simon Edward 04 Mar, 2024
When you get a divorce, the financial settlement will include any business assets. Find out more in our article.
Can AI be an inventor? Can a neural network be patented? Learn about AI and intellectual property
by Simon Edward 01 Mar, 2024
Can AI be an inventor? Can a neural network be patented? Learn about AI and intellectual property today.
When writing a will, words matter. Ambiguities and mistakes can lead to disputes
by Simon Edward 26 Feb, 2024
When writing a will, words matter. Ambiguities and mistakes can lead to disputes after the testator's death. Learn how they can be dealt with in our article.
Judgment has been handed down this week in Transwaste Recycling and Aggregates Ltd [2024] EWHC 330 (
by Gilly Storm 24 Feb, 2024
Judgment has been handed down this week in Transwaste Recycling and Aggregates Ltd [2024] EWHC 330 (Ch) after a three-week trial. Simon Bass and Oliver Cashman were instructed by the Respondents in this matter which was an unfair prejudice petition concerning a waste management company.
More posts
Share by: