When is a contract not a contract?

Simon Edward • Oct 23, 2023

Contracts aren't automatically valid. If badly written, they can be void and unenforceable. Discover more about contracts in our handy 5-minute guide.


Contracts aren't automatically valid. If badly written, they can be void and unenforceable. Discover more about contracts in our handy 5-minute guide.

We enter into contracts all the time – from purchase and rental agreements to the paperwork surrounding mortgages and tenancies.


But contracts aren't automatically valid. If they don't meet certain criteria, they can be declared by the courts to be "void", meaning that they can't be enforced. What's more, they're treated as though they never existed.


This means that you can't litigate in the case of a breach of agreement. It's void – you might as well chase a ghost or sue the wind.


Knowing what makes a contract a contract is essential for businesses of all shapes and sizes. From one point of view, your business is a house of cards built out of contracts – agreements with employees, clients, shareholders and partners. If one is declared void, it can create a lot of headaches.


Disputes can happen when contracts aren't legally binding. In these situations, you can find yourself enmeshed in a web of complex, stressful, time-consuming and expensive litigation.


It's really not worth it. That's why many
businesses choose to work with an experienced contract lawyer to help them write their contracts or simply to be a second pair of eyes.


It's much better to know in advance that your contracts are up to scratch than to find out down the line and have to deal with the consequences.


When is a contract "void"?


There are lots of different reasons why a contract could be unenforceable and therefore void. Here are some of the most common ones:


  • The terms of the contract are uncertain or vague.
  • The contract is an agreement about illegal activities.
  • It was written by someone who didn't have the authority to.
  • One party was coerced or manipulated into signing it,
  • One or both parties were under 18 when the contract was signed.
  • The contract is incomplete – for instance, it omits to mention starting dates or deadlines.


If a contract is declared void, that doesn't mean that your working relationship with the other party is dead in the water. It's entirely possible to enter into another agreement.


What's the difference between a void contract and a voidable one?


If a contract is void, it's treated as though it never existed. If it's "voidable", either party can rescind it. If the dispute ends up in court, the court can "set it aside".


There's also a distinction to be drawn with regard to third parties. If a contract is declared void, then any third parties mentioned in it lose their legal rights.


In the case of a contract that's voidable but not rescinded, third parties can continue to have their legal rights.


Why are contracts important?


Red tape can be frustrating – and you may wonder why you can't run a business on handshakes and verbal agreements. The main reason is that contracts provide clarity – and clarity helps to scotch legal disputes.


First, a contract helps build commitments within a business. All parties understand their roles, duties and processes. Everyone is entering into the agreement with their eyes wide open.


Picture of a contract being signed

Second, they help to prevent conflicts because they manage expectations. It's a bit like a dress code at a dinner party. If the invitation fails to mention that you should be wearing formal wear, you could be justifiably angry if you turn up in jeans. But if the dress code is announced ahead of time, there's less room for conflict.


The same is true of business contracts. A well-written contract should settle – and hopefully prevent – conflicts between managers, employees and third parties.


What's a "bargain"?


For a contract to be legally binding, it needs to include a bargain. This is an exchange – one party is doing something in exchange for the other party doing something else. The bargain usually (but not always) takes the form of money.


What's a dispute resolution clause?


A dispute resolution clause sets out what should happen in the event of a falling-out.


The UK court system is under a lot of strain, partly as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. There's a huge backlog of cases to be got through. This is why the government is pushing for people to resolve their problems through independent mediation and see legal action as a last resort.


Even if this weren't the case, legal action should be the last resort – and we say that as experienced solicitors. If you can troubleshoot a problem face-to-face or through a mediator, you should. But if all else fails, we can help you get the outcome you deserve.


What are "unfair" contract terms?


Unfair contract terms include "exclusion clauses", where one party attempts to avoid liability, and "penalty clauses" where the amount payable upon breach of contract is considered by the courts to be excessive.


Do contracts have to be in writing?


No – verbal contracts are made every day. However, it's preferable to have the agreement written down, signed and witnessed.


In the event of a dispute, it can be incredibly hard to prove that a verbal contract exists and to reiterate its terms and conditions. A written contract, on the other hand, can be readily consulted. There's no time wasted trying to prove that it exists.


Conclusion


Contracts are far from simple – and not just because they're peppered with Latin and legalese. Having a contract lawyer by your side means you can be sure that your contract is valid before you sign it.


Drafting contracts without legal help is possible – but you might end up in a conflict that eats up time, money and resources. A good contract lawyer will spare you those headaches and give you the confidence – and facts – you need to sign those contracts that help your business grow.


Are you looking for an experienced, non-judgmental commercial law solicitor to help you navigate the world of contracts? Get in touch with Milners today for a free, no-obligation consultation.


What happens to our online presence when we pass away? Learn how to navigate this
by Simon Edward 25 Mar, 2024
What happens to our online presence when we pass away? Learn how to navigate this "virtual estate".
It's been called the biggest miscarriage of justice in UK history. Learn about the Post Office
by Simon Edward 22 Mar, 2024
It's been called the biggest miscarriage of justice in UK history. Learn about the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry.
Are you looking to buy a house without a mortgage? You've got options. Find out more
by Simon Edward 18 Mar, 2024
Are you looking to buy a house without a mortgage? You've got options. Find out more in our explainer article.
Does inheritance tax apply to you? Find out in our handy guide to this commonly misunderstood issue.
by Simon Edward 15 Mar, 2024
Does inheritance tax apply to you? Find out in our handy guide to this commonly misunderstood issue.
Employment law distinguishes between workers and employees. Learn the difference
by Simon Edward 11 Mar, 2024
Employment law distinguishes between workers and employees. Learn the difference in our handy article.
What is criminal damage in British law? Join us as we explore the topic
by Simon Edward 08 Mar, 2024
What is criminal damage in British law? Join us as we explore the topic in our accessible 5-minute guide.
When you get a divorce, the financial settlement will include any business assets. Find out more
by Simon Edward 04 Mar, 2024
When you get a divorce, the financial settlement will include any business assets. Find out more in our article.
Can AI be an inventor? Can a neural network be patented? Learn about AI and intellectual property
by Simon Edward 01 Mar, 2024
Can AI be an inventor? Can a neural network be patented? Learn about AI and intellectual property today.
When writing a will, words matter. Ambiguities and mistakes can lead to disputes
by Simon Edward 26 Feb, 2024
When writing a will, words matter. Ambiguities and mistakes can lead to disputes after the testator's death. Learn how they can be dealt with in our article.
Judgment has been handed down this week in Transwaste Recycling and Aggregates Ltd [2024] EWHC 330 (
by Gilly Storm 24 Feb, 2024
Judgment has been handed down this week in Transwaste Recycling and Aggregates Ltd [2024] EWHC 330 (Ch) after a three-week trial. Simon Bass and Oliver Cashman were instructed by the Respondents in this matter which was an unfair prejudice petition concerning a waste management company.
More posts
Share by: