Following a protected conversation, an individual will normally be offered a settlement agreement, which is common. However, unless you have been through the process before it can be a stressful period as your continued employment is in question.
What is a protected conversation?
S111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 allows for protected conversations to occur between an employer and an employee. They are used to allow both parties to speak openly about issues and concerns within the workplace with a view to trying to reach a mutual understanding on how to move forward. Often the focus will be on how to terminate a contract of employment. The law allows for such discussions to take place without them being used as evidence in a potential unfair dismissal claim. They are similar to without prejudice discussions (see below).
However, not all protected conversations will be inadmissible and could be used as evidence. For example, if a protected conversation highlighted unfavourable treatment due to a protected characteristic, the individual could seek to rely upon this as evidence within a claim for discrimination.
In addition, one party cannot be seen as using improper behaviour (i.e. placing undue pressure to accept a settlement offer) during these conversations. If they have done so, it would strip the conversations of their protection – even when a claim is limited to an unfair dismissal claim.
As with without prejudice conversations, both an employer and employee can request a protected conversation, but the other party is under no obligation to enter the conversation. To ensure that a conversation meets the requirements, seeking legal advice prior to starting the process can assist to help ensure the discussions remain protected.
What is a without prejudice conversation?
A without prejudice conversation is a legal principle whereby parties to an existing dispute can communicate (both verbally and in writing) with a view to genuinely trying to settle such dispute without the fear of such communication then being used as evidence in future legal proceedings about the dispute in question.
To ensure such discussions remain protected under the without prejudice principle it is a requirement that there be an existing dispute, the parties wish to genuinely attempt to settle it and there has been no unambiguous impropriety on either party. If this is not the case the conversations could be used as evidence.
These types of conversations can be problematic as it is not always clear whether a dispute will meet the requirements for any settlement discussions to remain confidential. Seeking legal advice at an early stage can help reduce these risks.
What is a settlement agreement?
It is a formal document which sets out terms and conditions agreed by two parties, namely an employer and an employee. The purpose of the agreement is normally to terminate an employment contract and agree a settlement of any potential employment tribunal claim, without an admission of liability.
Why have you been offered a settlement agreement?
An employment contract can only be terminated in a limited number of ways, either by the employee resigning or termination by the employer. The fair reasons to terminate are due to capability issues, conduct issues, redundancy, a statutory restriction meaning that they cannot complete their duties as a result or some other substantial reason.
However, even if an employer has a fair reason to dismiss an individual, they also must follow a fair process. Failure on either part could result in an unfair dismissal claim.
A settlement agreement is likely to be offered in various situations, for example:-
- There are concerns about a potential claim and a settlement agreement will limit the risk to the employer (because certain employment rights are waived if an agreement is signed);
- To achieve a clean break between the parties without fear of repercussions i.e. there is a redundancy situation, but the parties have agreed not to follow a complete consultation process;
- There is a breakdown in the employer/employee relationship which is impacting upon both parties meaning a person cannot continue in that role effectively;
- To reinforce terms of employment following an agreed termination of the contract i.e. confidentiality provisions, restrictive covenants.
What should you do if you are offered a settlement agreement?
If offered a settlement agreement the individual will be afforded a reasonable amount of time (at least 10 days) to consider the contents of the agreement, seek legal advice and decide whether to accept and sign the agreement or not.
If you are offered an agreement, you should seek legal advice as soon as possible.
Why do you need legal advice on a settlement agreement?
There are certain requirements to ensure a settlement agreement will be valid. These include seeking independent legal advice on both the terms of the agreement, the effect of the agreement and any ability to seek a claim within the Employment Tribunal (or Courts).
When legal advice is provided, the representative will do the following:-
- Discuss the situation and background of why a settlement agreement has been offered. This will include the details of any protected conversation held and any concerns the individual may have regarding treatment within the workplace. Without all relevant information the legal advisor cannot fully advise on the options available.
- Review and advise upon the terms and conditions of the agreement and what this will mean for the individual if they sign. If they do sign, they would be giving up the ability to bring a claim within a Tribunal or Court. To balance this, a compensation payment (or termination payment) will form part of the settlement agreement.
This is why seeking independent legal advice is a legal requirement.
What are the benefits of a settlement agreement for an individual?
Whilst daunting, a settlement agreement can be an asset to both employers and individuals. It gives certainty and a clean break to both parties in a relatively short time frame.
The main benefits are that in addition to being paid contractual rights up to an agreed termination date, an individual will likely receive a compensation payment for loss of office and waiving certain rights, which can be paid tax free up to a maximum of £30,000.
Contractual payments will include normal salary and benefits up to an agreed termination date, accrued holiday allowance and, payment of notice period (sometimes as a payment in lieu of notice where a contract of employment allows). It is important to note that contractual payments will be subject to normal deductions for tax and national insurance.
As there is a requirement to seek legal advice an employer will normally contribute towards legal costs. For a straightforward agreement within minimal changes and negotiation required, it would cost in the region of £500 to £700 plus VAT.
What are the consequences of a settlement agreement for an individual?
By signing the agreement certain rights are waived to be able to bring a claim against the employer for a particular complaint or complaints.
In addition, reaching a settlement under a settlement agreement rather than pursuing a claim at an Employment Tribunal (i.e. unfair dismissal, discrimination) may be for a lesser amount of compensation due to several factors.
The individual will also find themselves out of work and potentially with post termination restrictions in force which would need to be considered prior to starting a new role elsewhere.
What are the options if offered a settlement agreement?
There is no obligation to enter into discussions about a potential settlement agreement nor is there any obligation upon an individual to sign and accept the terms of a settlement agreement once provided and once the legal advice has been sought.
The options available are:-
- Accept the agreement and sign as required. At this point, the agreement would become binding on both parties.
- Look to re-negotiate the terms of the agreement. Upon receiving legal advice, it may be apparent that the individual has strong prospects of success in bringing a claim or claims against their employer. If this is the case, then additional compensation could be sought from the employer by way of a further period of negotiation.
- Reject the agreement. This is likely to be the only option if the settlement offered is poor and the employer is not willing to negotiate a more favourable outcome. Where this happens, the individual would remain employed and internal processes are likely to continue i.e. the commencement of redundancy processes or disciplinary process. In the alternative if the individual has raised allegations of unfair treatment and a breakdown of the relationship then the employer should make effort to resolve these.
If the employer fails to follow fair and reasonable processes, if a settlement is not finalised, it could make them vulnerable to claims for unfair dismissal if the contract is terminated soon thereafter (consideration on whether the discussion should be deemed to be without prejudice or protected would come into question).
As with any workplace misunderstanding or dispute obtaining independent advice at an early stage for both employer and employee is highly beneficial.
Milners have a wealth of experience in advising on how to hold a protected conversation to benefit you, as well as advising on and drafting Settlement Agreements.
If you find yourself in a situation where you wish to obtain a settlement agreement, have been offered a settlement agreement or wish to approach an individual about entering discussions to terminate an employment contract then please contact Milners’ Employment Team.











