The Blog

Milners secures landmark victory against age discrimination in law Firms

by | Mar 13, 2025 | For Business, For you

Judgment was handed down last month in the Scott v Walker Morris LLP ET/1806503/2023 after the trial in December 2024. Giles Ward, senior partner here at Milners, was instructed after Martin Scott was forcibly removed from his position as partner at Walker Morris LLP due to his age. The case has brought to light key issues with mandatory retirement policies and the risk of age discrimination.  

As hard as we might try to stop it, we all age. Ageing is perhaps our most unifying characteristic but despite this age discrimination is often taken less seriously than other forms of discrimination. 

Defined as treating someone less favourably due to their age, age discrimination is legislated against under the Equality Act 2010, meaning that you are protected from discrimination based on your age at work. This doesn’t just apply to employees of a business in the standard sense but also to partners and LLP members. However, despite legislation to prevent age discrimination, it is recognised as being ‘widespread,’ ‘pervasive,’ and ‘culturally embedded’ in the United Kingdom and it is one of only two protected characteristics under the Equality Act that direct discrimination can be legally justified under a narrow set of circumstances. The use of Mandatory Retirement Policies (“MRPs”) in professional service industries are examples of direct discrimination on the grounds of age. Whether or not their use can be justified has become a topic of debate over recent years, with big accountancy firms like Deloitte’s being subjected to legal claims, and EY extending the tenure of their UK boss passed the retirement age. 

While the default retirement age of 65 was abolished in 2011, mandatory retirement age policies continued in the professional services industry. Law firms and other professional service partnerships have historically defended them as a way in which opportunities are created for younger partners, with stereotypes around the older partner who does very little work but continues to take a large share of the profits, helping to justify these policies. But should firms be able to rely on these stereotypes in order to push out older partners? Well recent court decisions suggest no. While there are some restrictive circumstances in which age discrimination can be legally justified (as a proportionate way of achieving a legitimate aim), firms can no longer use social policy aims like intergenerational fairness without evidence to back up their claims. 

The recent unanimous decision by an Employment Tribunal in Leeds reflects just that. After Mr Martin Scott was forced out of his job as partner of law firm Walker Morris where he had worked for over 30 years, he brought a successful claim against the firm for age discrimination. The firm claimed that it was necessary to enforce mandatory retirement in order to ensure ‘intergenerational fairness’ and while the tribunal noted this was a legitimate social policy aim, there was ‘very little evidence’ before the tribunal that supported ‘a conclusion that forcing partners to retire age 63 was reasonably necessary for workforce and succession planning.’ Particularly significant was the decision by Walker Morris to apply different performance criteria to partners over the age of 60, who were only allowed to stay on in their jobs if they were considered likely to meet the ‘exceptional’ criteria required for those over 60. The Tribunal found that Walker Morris’ approach was encouraged by ‘discriminatory assumptions about and attitudes towards older partners.’

So what are the justifications for the use of mandatory retirement policies? There are restricted circumstances where enforcement of these policies could be justified, but only if they can evidence that the discriminatory treatment is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. In order to justify this, the firms must show the following: 

  1. That they are pursuing a legitimate public policy aim. 
  2. That the aim is relevant to their specific circumstance and supported by evidence 
  3. That the MRP is proportionate and a necessary way of achieving the legitimate aims
  4. And that other approached have been considered, including whether there are other less discriminatory means of achieving their aims. 

Therefore, it is not enough to merely say that the policies are there to achieve legitimate aims, significant evidence must demonstrate the fact.

While it is clear that a small minority of firms continue to hold onto outdated policies, the vast majority of firms have scrapped mandatory age requirements for partners. Research carried out on Partners Retirement in Law Firms demonstrates that the majority of law firms in the UK have moved away from mandatory retirement ages in order to mitigate claims of age discrimination, concluding that only performance and contribution are the right criteria to apply when making decisions about the partnership. This reflects changing attitudes about age but also a changing legal industry, where partners are often at the height of their careers at 60, with longstanding client relationships that firms are eager to maintain. 

Giles Ward, a senior partner here at Milners, noted that the decision against Walker Morris will be of obvious interest to firms that continue to use these policies, and will serve as a ‘warning bell’ to the professional services industry. Ultimately age, like all other protected characteristics, is not a good indicator of how much an employee or partner can contribute to a firm, and employers should be careful that they avoid relying on discriminatory stereotypes in order to justify their policies. 

Milners Solicitors, Hugh Tomlinson KC and Darryl Hutcheon from Matrix Chambers represent Mr Scott.

FAQs:

  1. What legislation protects employees from discrimination on the grounds of age at work? The Equality Act 2010 which also incorporates the Employment Equality (Age) regulations. 
  2. What are the types of age discrimination under the Equality Act? The Act provides protection against direct discrimination, indirect discrimination, harassment and victimization.
  3. Does the protection only relate to older people? No, the Equality Act covers all ages. 
  4. What should you do if you have been a victim of ageism in the workplace? Firstly it is recommended that you follow your employer’s grievance procedures. However if you are unsatisfied with the result you should seek legal advice. 
  5. How long do I have to bring a claim for age discrimination? Claims should be issued within 3 months of the date of dismissal or alleged discriminatory act.

 

READ MORE

Latest From The Blog

5 Star Rated

Client testimonials

Get your FREE no-obligation consultation

We offer a free, no-obligation 30-minute consultation to help you understand whether our services are right for you. Please note that this initial meeting is for general discussion only and does not include legal advice.

Completely FREE
No Obligation
Friendly & Welcoming