In their 2024 manifesto titled “Change”, the Labour Party promised an investigation or inquiry into the events at Orgreave. The manifesto promise refers of course, to the events which became more infamously known, as the Battle of Orgreave on 18 June 1984; one of the most prominent events of the 1984-85 Miners’ Strikes.
Perhaps drawing on tactics from the 1972 miners’ strike, the NUM organised a mass picket at Orgreave to prevent strike-breaking lorries from transporting coke from Orgreave, for use at blast furnaces at the Scunthorpe steelworks. During the 1972 strikes, mass pickets had overwhelmed police and, perhaps learning from that history, around 6,000 police officers were deployed to meet roughly 5,000 striking miners.
What followed was a bloody battle where miners were corralled into a field where retreat was difficult or impossible; they were then subject to a series of charges by mounted police, baton beatings and shield charges.
95 miners were charged with rioting, unlawful assembly and other public order offences, though the trials collapsed owing to a finding that the evidence offered by the police was unreliable. Civil claims on behalf of the miners followed for wrongful arrest, unlawful detention and malicious prosecution; South Yorkshire Police ultimately settled these claims.
On 21 July 2025, the Home Secretary announced an inquiry into the violent confrontation at Orgreave, in fulfilment of Labour’s manifesto promise. The Inquiry is to be panel-led and chaired by the Rt Revd Dr Pete Wilcox, Bishop of Sheffield.
The interesting question is what form will the Inquiry take? The Inquiries Act 2005, and the Inquiry Rules 2006 permit a broad discretion as to how public inquiries go about their business, providing always that they act within their terms of reference.
Perhaps inevitably, there has always been a strong link between the Battle of Orgreave and the Hillsborough Disaster because both involved the policing tactics and responses of South Yorkshire Police during the 1980s; indeed, calls for an Orgreave inquiry really reemerged after the Hillsborough review which reported in 2012.
Following the announcement of the Orgreave Inquiry, there was press speculation that it would follow the format of the Hillsborough review; this might be because of the historic association between the two events or because both are chaired by cleric-led panels, but the first important thing to note is that the Hillsborough review was not a statutory public inquiry.
The Hillsborough Independent Panel were charged with overseeing the release and publication of relevant documents as well as producing a report on the content of those documents. Is a document review likely to satisfy miners who were present at Orgreave in 1984? Is it likely to give the relevant police forces adequate opportunities to respond?
Many take the view that the Infected Blood Inquiry, chaired by Sir Brian Langstaff, sets a benchmark for public inquiries in terms not only of dealing with an historic injustice compassionately and thoughtfully, but in conducting a detailed and complex investigation “as swiftly as reasonable thoroughness permits”.
Sir Brian had initially hoped that the Infected Blood Inquiry would take two to three years; it produced its Report in May 2024, six years after work proper had commenced. This wasn’t because Sir Brian’s initial time estimate was hopelessly optimistic – he is a High Court Judge who is enormously experienced in timetabling legal proceedings. The Inquiry took six years because once it began to interrogate the documentary evidence in hearings, it variously opened other avenues of investigation, showed that documents weren’t what they appeared to be on their face, or showed that the documents represented only a small part of the story.
Equally, the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry chaired by Sir Wyn Williams, shows the difficulties that can be faced when an emanation of the State, is reluctant with its disclosure. How does a document review or paper-based inquiry really get to the bottom of issues of missing documents without taking oral evidence? It can of course demand written statements but the answers in those statements are unlikely to be as frank as those given during the course of an oral hearing.
There is inevitably a trade-off between the length of time an inquiry takes and the thoroughness of its investigation. Campaigners might take the view that they will sacrifice an exhaustive investigation, in order to receive a report sooner.
Campaigners and Government should be cautious in making such a trade-off: the 1990s and 2000s were littered with examples of inquiries branded as ‘whitewashes’ for not undertaking a thorough investigation.
Equally, the Al-Sweady Inquiry ought to have taught Government the value of a thorough investigation; Sir Thayne Forbes concluded after a five-year investigation, that allegations of murder and torture levelled against the British Army following the Battle of Danny Boy in Iraq, were “wholly without foundation and entirely the product of deliberate lies, reckless speculation and ingrained hostility.”
Unfortunately, public inquiries are commenced to examine the most serious failures of the State; these are not issues which can be properly understood through a brief investigation or even in some circumstances, a thorough document review. Inquiries take time to do their work properly, but that doesn’t mean that they are inefficient; there is a public interest in examining failures of the State and time is the price that is paid for that work.
Whilst public consultation into the terms of reference and format of the Orgreave Inquiry is ongoing, those likely to be core-participants should give much thought to the extent to which they are prepared to trade a thorough investigation, for a quick resolution.
Ben Harrison is Head of Public Law at Milners Solicitors and has worked on the Infected Blood Inquiry, the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse, Grenfell Tower Inquiry and a number of others. Milners Solicitors are not currently instructed in relation to the Orgreave Inquiry.











