With an ever-growing number of commercial properties lying empty in the high street in towns and cities across England and Wales, the government has been keen to step in to try and revive and regenerate these areas. Statistics suggest that one in 7 shops in the UK are now vacant, and the figure is even higher in the North East and the Midlands.
On 10 July 2025, the English Devolution & Community Empowerment Bill was published. The government states the Bill aims to make “leases fairer for tenants, the market more efficient and ultimately contribute to thriving high streets and economic growth”.
To this end, and rather unexpectedly, the Bill includes a provision that bans upward only rent review clauses in all new commercial leases, including renewal leases.
But will the ban have the desired effect?
Background
For decades it has been standard practice for commercial leases to provide for upward only rent reviews (“UORR”). This ensures the agreed rent can only ever go up or remain static. There is no remit for the rent to go down, even when the market deteriorates. On the one hand, this approach gives landlords, investors and lenders the comfort of a secure and predictable income and a level of certainty which encourages investment, particularly for pension funds seeking reliable returns; but on the other hand, the government argues UORR clauses have led to abnormally high rents during economic downturns placing pressure on small business and unfairly high profits for landlords.
The proposed ban on UORR has sent ripples of shock through much of the real estate sector, made worse by the lack of prior consultation and fears about the possible impact on the broader real estate market and general investment.
What types of leases are affected?
The government claims the measure will ‘prevent vacant shops and regenerate high streets.” However, the legislation is a lot more far-reaching than that. The Bill applies to all new commercial leases granted to tenants for business purposes (regardless of whether they have security of tenure or not) and is not limited to retail premises alone. (The only exceptions are non-profit making businesses (such as sports clubs) and agricultural/mining leases).
Will the ban affect existing leases?
UORR clauses in existing leases will fall outside the scope of the ban, and they will be able to run their course. The ban will not be retrospective.
However, these leases could find themselves affected in other ways. For example, if an existing lease contains a clause that requires an underlease to include an UORR provision, this will be of no effect, and the superior landlord would have no say in the rent review terms included in that underlease.
What could be the consequences?
There are concerns that the ban will essentially not deliver its primary objective.
Recent data suggests that 90% of new commercial leases in England and Wales are for terms of less than 5 years and therefore unlikely to include any rent review provisions at all.
Many take the view that vacant units on the high street are more a symptom of e-commerce and changes in consumer behaviour, rather than tenants being trapped in long term leases with inflated rents.
It is perhaps more likely that the ‘broad brush’ approach of the ban will have the following unintentional outcomes instead:
- Shorter lease terms – potentially disrupting business planning and stability.
- Landlords demanding higher initial rents to offset the risk of future rent reduction.
- Fewer lease renewal protections and more contracted out leases.
- Potential fixed rent increases (eg index linked or stepped rent increases).
- Reduced incentives (eg fewer rent-free periods and fit out contributions from landlords).
Are there ways round this?
The Bill contains several anti-avoidance provisions to ensure the Bill takes effect as intended. It will be hard, if not impossible, to get round the legislation contractually, even by experienced, well-advised parties who agree to try to do that.
The legislation will enable tenants to trigger and progress rent reviews, so landlords will not be able to get round this by sitting on their hands and not triggering a review.
Furthermore, no cap on rent reductions will be allowed in the lease.
Any attempt to add a provision to the lease that requires a tenant to make an additional payment to cover the amount of any rent reduction will also be invalid.
When could the ban become law?
The Bill will require a lot of parliamentary time and discussion. The earliest date it could come into force would be very late this year, but it’s expected to take much longer. Industry lobbying is likely to cause significant delays, especially because of the lack of consultation prior to the Bill being published.
Are there alternative options for the government?
The government may decide to water down their proposal and options might include:
- The ban being limited to high street retail leases and only in certain geographic areas.
- Encouraging market linked rent reviews through tax breaks or grants for landlords and thereby preserving the current contractual freedom that exists.
- Introducing the ban in phased zones (eg where there are many vacant properties) to gain an understanding of the potential effects in advance of its wider introduction.
While the position remains uncertain, what can be done?
Current transactions and those in the pipeline should be reviewed to assess any potential exposure should the ban take effect.
Agreements for lease in advance of the ban taking effect, could be considered as a means of preserving the existing rent review position.
Landlords may look to vary their existing leases to exclude any offending UORR requirement on underletting before the Bill becomes law, to safeguard their control over other rent review terms in future underleases.
Only time will tell whether the ban will become law and whether it will revive the high street as hoped. If the ban goes through it will certainly be one of the most significant changes commercial leasing has seen for many years.











