Behind the Judgment: What OS v DT [2025] EWFC 156 (B) Means for Families
It is quite likely that most families with children who are separating have heard of ‘child maintenance’, ‘CMS’ or ‘child support’ but what does it actually mean; who decides what it should be; and how is it obtained?
A recent court decision by HHJ Hess marks a significant development in child maintenance law, clarifying the court’s jurisdiction to order ‘child periodical payments’ (maintenance), rather than the Child Maintenance Service (CMS) where parents share the care of their children exactly equally.
Equal Shared Care: Who decides who pays?
It has generally been the position that child maintenance could only be obtained from the Child Maintenance Service and therefore not from the family court (Child Support Act 1991).
However, this recent court decision has provided clarity to this point in considering Regulation 50 of the Child Support Maintenance Calculation Regulations 2012 and the distinctive position in cases where there is exactly equal shared care. The CMS only has jurisdiction where one parent provides less day-to-day care than the other. Where care is shared equally, there is no “non-resident parent”, and consequently no CMS assessment can be made.
Since the regulation came into force, uncertainty has remained as to whether the CMS retains jurisdiction but would potentially assess maintenance at £0, or whether it lacks jurisdiction altogether, leaving the court free to make an order.
HHJ Hess judgement resolved key uncertainties arising from the 2012 regulations by clarifying the position:
- In cases of exactly equal shared care, the CMS has no jurisdiction under regulation 50;
- As the CMS cannot act, the statutory bar in section 8(1) and 8(3) of the Child Support Act 1991 does not apply;
- The Court retains its power under section 23(1)(d) of the MCA 1973 to make a child periodical payments order;
- A party does not have to apply to the CMS first, the Court can decide whether there is equal care and can make an assessment on that basis.
Therefore arguably (and no doubt there will be arguments) if parents share exact equal care of their children they cannot utilise the CMS and instead need to seek help from the family courts if child maintenance is sought.
Case Background
The case concerned a high-value financial remedies dispute involving assets in excess of £9 million, including investments, bonuses, share awards and pensions. The husband had significantly greater wealth and earning capacity, while the wife left her career in finance to raise the children and later returned to work on a part-time basis. The proceedings also raised disputes concerning non-matrimonial property, including post-separation income and child periodical payments where the parties had equal shared care of their children.
The parties began cohabitating in 2009, married in 2014, and separated in 2023. They had three children aged 10 and under, attending fee-paying schools in London. The family lived first at the husband’s sole-owned flat in 2011, then at the jointly owned family home until separation as the parties began to live separately.
Judgment and Outcome in OS V DT
After consideration and determination in relation to whether the court had jurisdiction to make child periodical payments, which the court found it did, on the assessment of the facts HHJ Hess ultimately declined to order maintenance. The parents shared care of the children equally, they held substantial capital (just over £3.44 million each), both had strong income earning capacities and the father was facing redundancy. In these circumstances, child periodical payments were not deemed necessary or fair.
Subsequently, the court ordered the father to pay 75% of the children’s school fees, reflecting his greater resources and earning capacity. This underscores that once jurisdiction is established, the court retains the authority to make targeted financial provisions for the children, even where standard periodical maintenance is deemed inappropriate.
Impact on Separated Families
This judgment confirms that in equal shared-care cases, the court is the relevant body to deal with child maintenance disputes. However, it is likely this judgment will only lead to further conflict between parties when they are establishing whether care is exactly equal and this may encourage litigation over care arrangements, not just for welfare reasons but for jurisdictional and potentially cost advantages. Furthermore, clear caution needs to be exercised as the Court are yet to determine how maintenance should be calculated in these cases if the CMS are no longer used as a starting point.
Currently, the court’s intervention in assessment of maintenance is in respect of ‘top-up order’ CMS cases, where a non-resident party’s income is over £156k. In such cases, the court can consider the ‘standard’ CMS calculation on the first £156k as a mandatory starting point. Once the maximum CMS assessment is met, the Court may order additional payments based on the income exceeding this threshold to meet a child’s needs using similar criteria as the CMS, which is usually an income up to £650,000 per year. However, is this the right matrix or, if the family court holds jurisdiction, should the maintenance be simply calculated on a needs basis, following the s25 MCA guidance and the specific circumstances of the case?
If it is the former, this should be a relatively easy exercise for the court to conduct, however if it is the latter this could well extend court time for assessments, in a system where courts are already struggling to manage the case lists.
FAQS
- Why does this case matter for parents?
Equal shared care does not automatically mean that there will not be any maintenance. If care is exactly equal, then CMS may not be able to help but it appears that the court certainly can. It is important for parents to consider what the current child arrangements look like as there may be disputes between the parties in relation to whether caring for the child is equal in practice and whether day-to-day responsibilities are shared, not just overnight stays. Again, these small factual differences could affect jurisdiction so it is something that parents should be cautious of when considering or going through proceedings.
- I am a father seeking equal shared care, will I still have to pay child maintenance?
The answer could be yes; you need to be aware that a direct application could now be made to the Family Court as they have Jurisdiction to make further bespoke financial provisions for the children and in relation to making child maintenance orders.
If you have equal shared care, you may not be required to pay regular maintenance through CMS, but the Court can make targeted financial orders to ensure the children’s needs are met, particularly if one parent has significantly greater resources.
- Both my ex-partner and I have shared care of the children, am I still entitled to claim for child maintenance?
Previously, parents may have thought they were not entitled to anything if the parties agreed to have shared equal care of the children. However, this is no longer the case as you may have a very good case for child maintenance before the court, depending on the financial circumstances of the parties and whether such a claim would be necessary and just in the circumstances.
- Does this judgement apply to unmarried couples?
Although the judgement by HHJ Hess focuses primarily on child maintenance jurisdiction in high-value financial remedies following the breakdown of a long marriage, its principles regarding child maintenance in equal shared care scenarios can also be applied to unmarried couples. For unmarried parents, the Court would rely on Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989 to make child maintenance and financial provision orders for children where CMS does not have jurisdiction.
- Practical Tips
We would always advocate that court proceedings should be a last resort. Sometimes, particularly if one parent has significantly higher income than the other, the parties could try and resolve such disparity by creating an agreed schedule of costs for the children. This could include items such as technology; school uniform; shoes; coats; pocket money and so on. Items could be agreed to be discharged in full by one parent, or shared perhaps in an unequal percentage to reflect income. Assistance in creating, negotiating and drafting such schedules could be done between parents or if this is causing difficulties, through mediation or through solicitors.
- What support does Milners Solicitors offer?
We offer a 30-minute, free, initial appointment by telephone or in-person at one of our offices with one of our family law solicitors who can discuss your case further, provide you with timescales and quotes and outline what options are available to you going forward.











