A very wise person once said, “where there are properties, there are property disputes”.
Ahem. Well, actually, as a law firm we’re obliged to point out that a wise person didn’t say that. We just made it up.
But you get the point: property disputes are not uncommon. Take our word for it – we deal with loads of them. And many of them arise over the same sorts of issues.
We realise this isn’t very helpful if you’ve found yourself caught in a conflict about a property. Sure, there are lots of disputes happening right now, but that doesn’t take away from the stress and hassle of your own dispute.
And they are stressful and they are a hassle. You might be arguing with a neighbour about a hedge or involved in a complex contractual dispute with a property developer. Either way, it’s likely taking up valuable mental real estate that you’d rather save for happier, less irritating thoughts.
So let’s talk solutions. Let’s consider the various methods you can use to resolve disputes and move on with your life.
Hint: one of them is litigation, but this should probably be your last resort.
Alternative dispute resolution methods
Alternative dispute resolution, or ADR, means a way of resolving disputes that avoids litigation. There are several types of ADR but, for now, we’ll focus on negotiation, mediation and arbitration. You don’t have to try the methods in this order, but it’s often recommended.
Negotiation
Negotiation is just what it sounds like – sitting down with the other party and trying to straighten things out.
Negotiation differs from other ADR methods because it only includes the parties who are involved in the dispute. While a solicitor might advise that you try negotiation, there is no formal involvement from an outside professional – legal or otherwise.
Say you’re involved in a residential property dispute. Your neighbour installed a new fence and your garden mysteriously shed a good 20 square metres in the process. Beginning a negotiation could be as simple – and informal – as inviting them round for a cup of tea and a friendly(ish) chat.
If both parties are ready to compromise, then you might just sort things out for the price of two teabags. If things get a little heated (and they often do), then you might want to consider the next method – mediation.
Mediation
If negotiation is completely informal, then mediation can be considered somewhat formal. It’s not as strict and rigorous as court proceedings, but it’s unlikely you’ll be able to resolve matters in 40 minutes at the kitchen table, either.
And unlike negotiation, mediation does involve another person. Your talks will be overseen by a professional called a mediator.
Mediators don’t make decisions or take sides. It’s their job to help you come to a mutually agreeable resolution by acting as a neutral and independent third party.
We won’t get into the nuts and bolts of the mediation process here (see this article for that). Instead, let’s look at an example that helps explain how the process works:
You’re a commercial property developer. You find yourself in a dispute with your contractor about work not being completed on time.
Negotiations have failed. You’ve reached an impasse. Any attempts to reach out are met with hostility from the other side.
Your solicitor recommends mediation. Your contractor agrees. The two parties choose a mediator and book a date for a one-day mediation session.
During the session, the mediator talks to the affected parties together and separately. The mediation process helps guide discussions and stop tempers from fraying. By the end of the session, you’re able to come to a compromise with the other party.
While this might be an imaginary mediation success story, it’s not unusual. One of mediation’s strengths is its success rate – as high as 90%, by one estimate.
It’s also very flexible. Mediation focuses on the facts of your dispute and isn’t bound by the strict regulations of court.
However, mediation doesn’t always succeed. If you’re still at a deadlock, your options are litigation or – often preferably – arbitration.
Arbitration
So negotiation is informal and mediation is kind of formal. Arbitration, by comparison, is very formal. It’s not quite “High-Court” formal, but it’s getting there.
And, indeed, arbitration is a little like a court hearing in miniature. You’ll present your case to a professional called an arbitrator and they’ll make a decision based on formal legal rules. In this sense, an arbitrator is like a judge and the disputing parties are like claimants and respondents.
The arbitrator’s decision is legally binding. No ifs, no buts – you have to accept what the arbitrator decides.
This makes arbitration less flexible but more final than negotiation or mediation. It’s useful if you’ve tried the other ADR methods and have got nowhere – or if your property dispute has become so heated that you can’t stand to be in the same room as the other party.
“But,” you might be wondering, “if arbitration is like a miniature court case, why not go straight to court?”
Let’s find out.
The final option: litigation
If all other ADR methods have failed, you might have little choice but to take your case to court.
The problem with litigation is that it can be costly, time-consuming and stressful. For these reasons, we often recommend that litigation is used as a last resort.
Sometimes, courts do too. They might insist that you at least try ADR before mounting a legal challenge.
Even compared to arbitration – the most formal of the ADR methods we’ve covered – court hearings can be expensive and lengthy. Arbitration can be completed within a few weeks. And while it costs money, these costs will usually be shared between the disputing parties.
If you lose your court case, however, you might end up shouldering the winner’s legal fees.
Still, sometimes there’s no option but to litigate. And if you decide this is the right option for you, we’re here to help.
Our property litigation experts pride themselves on their speed and proactivity. We’ll tailor our approach to your case and work hard to achieve an agreeable result with minimal cost.
And, yes, we can help with mediation and arbitration too.
For more information, see our page about property dispute resolution. Or get in touch for a free, no-obligation legal consultation.











