If you find yourself in a situation whereby you have been dismissed from work, you are likely to believe that this is “unfair” and want to try and right the wrong against you. This is understandable but legally, you can only bring a claim for unfair dismissal in certain circumstances. In addition, there are circumstances where an employer can fairly terminate a contract of employment.
What is a fair reason to dismiss?
There are five potentially fair reasons for dismissal under section 98 of the Employment Rights Act 1996. These are: capability or qualifications, conduct, redundancy, breach of a statutory duty or restriction or some other substantial reason (“SOSR”). The reason for dismissal may fall into more than one of the five potentially fair categories, as there can be an overlap.
SOSR is a dismissal which does not fall within what is deemed as a fair reason for dismissal. An example would be where an employee and employer have a personality clash or, where an employer lets you go after a fixed term contract. It is important to note that each case will be determined on its own facts and our specialist employment lawyers would be able to assist with this.
Who has the right to claim unfair dismissal?
Only employees have the right to not be unfairly dismissed. An employee must have 2 years or more of continuous service to be eligible to bring a claim. There are exceptions to this requirement if the dismissal is classed as an automatically unfair reason for dismissal (see below). A dismissal will be deemed as unfair when an employee is dismissed from their job in a harsh, unjust or unreasonable way. This must be shown by (1) there is no statutory fair reason for the dismissal and/or (2) the employer has failed to follow a fair and reasonable process when reaching the decision to dismiss the individual. It will be for the employer to show that they acted reasonably in all the circumstances,
An example of a failure is if they did not comply with the ACAS Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures, if the reason is in relation to unacceptable or inappropriate behaviour or performance (unless it is related to illness) then the dismissal may be deemed unfair.
Automatically unfair reasons for dismissals
There are certain scenarios that are ‘automatically unfair’ if they are the reason for the dismissal:
- Discrimination on specific grounds (e.g. sex or race);
- An employee making a flexible working request;
- An employee being pregnant or on maternity leave;
- An employee wanting to take leave for parental, paternity or adoption;
- An employee being a trade union member or representative;
- An employee asking for a legal employee right;
- An employee being called to jury service;
- An employee being involved in whistleblowing;
- Compulsory retirement;
- An employee taking action, or proposing to take action, over a health and safety issue; and
- Where an employee is dismissed due to a business transfer.
Are there any exclusions from the right to claim where a dismissal would be otherwise unfair?
In certain circumstances, an employee would be prevented from bringing a claim for unfair dismissal, these include:
- Where an employment contract is illegal or has been performed illegally. A common form of illegality in an employment contract would be if an employee does not have the right to work in the UK.
- If you have entered into a Settlement Agreement that will restrict your right to bring that particular claim. Entering into a Settlement Agreement means you will waive all your employment rights to bring a claim for unfair dismissal.
- Where a claim has been brought already and the employment tribunal has either struck out or settled the claim or where you have withdrawn your claim.
- A claim for unfair dismissal must be presented within a period of three months starting with the effective date of termination.
Compensation
The compensation for a successful claim for unfair dismissal will be made up of a basic award and a compensatory award.
The basic award takes consideration the person’s age and is made up of:
- One and a half weeks’ pay for each year of employment after age 41;
- One week’s pay for each year of employment between ages 22 and 40;
- Half a week’s pay for each year of employment under the age of 22.
The weekly pay which is used to work out the basic award payment will usually be your normal weekly gross pay at the time you were dismissed up to the maximum limit which is £700. The maximum basic award payment you can receive is £21,000, as there is a cap on the number of years you can claim, currently this is 20 years.
Once the basic award has been established, a compensatory award will then be considered.
The Employment Rights Act provides that the compensatory award will be “such amount as the Tribunal considers just and equitable in all the circumstances having regard to the loss sustained by the complainant in consequence of the dismissal insofar as that loss is attributable to action taken by the employer”. This means that the losses which arise must be as a direct result of you being dismissed in an unfair manner. The losses that will be considered when establishing a compensatory award that is just and equitable are:
- loss of wages;
- loss of future wages;
- loss of statutory rights; and
- loss of pension.
Does this include benefits?
Yes, but they must be contractual benefits. If an employee is seeking to claim for loss of bonus or commission, this can be claimed as a loss even if it is discretionary if the employee reasonably expected to receive this payment.
Is there a maximum amount of compensatory award?
Determining a compensatory award will always be uncertain and we would not be able to give definitive figures as this is entirely at the tribunals discretion on what they deem to be appropriate. A key factor in determining this award is if the employee has made efforts to mitigate their loss and any alternative employment as at the date of the hearing.
The maximum amount that you can be awarded as compensation for unfair dismissal at present, is the statutory cap of £115,115.00 or 52 weeks gross salary, whichever is lower.
In some instances, there is no cap on the compensatory award for unfair dismissal where the claim includes other claims, such as discrimination.
If you feel like you have been unfairly dismissed or you are an employer who is subject to an unfair dismissal claim, please contact Milners’ Employment team to discuss your options.











